Skip to main content
Housing Market 2026Cash Home BuyersReal Estate TrendsHome Selling Strategy

Why Some US Home Prices Are Still Climbing While Others Stall

A market-by-market look at where US home prices are still rising in 2026, where they've stalled, and what that split means for sellers, buyers, and investors.

By John Muss·October 23, 2026·7 min read
Why Some US Home Prices Are Still Climbing While Others Stall

The "national housing market" stopped being one thing a long time ago, but 2026 is the year the split became impossible to ignore. Some metros are still posting 4-6% annual price gains with homes going under contract in under two weeks. Others, many of them the same Sun Belt cities that doubled in value between 2020 and 2022, are sitting flat or giving back 5-10% of their pandemic-era run-up, with listings parked on the market for 60, 90, even 120 days.

If you're selling, buying, or holding rental property, the question isn't "how's the housing market doing." It's "how is my specific zip code doing, and what does that mean for my timeline." Here's how to read the split and what to do about it.

The Pattern Behind the Split

Three forces are driving where prices hold and where they don't.

First, mortgage rates have stayed in the high-5s to mid-6s for most of 2025 and into 2026, which keeps monthly payments elevated even where list prices haven't moved. That payment math hits harder in markets where incomes didn't grow as fast as prices did during the boom.

Second, the migration pattern that fueled Sun Belt growth from 2020 to 2023 has slowed. Remote workers who moved to Austin, Boise, or Tampa for space and lower taxes are facing return-to-office mandates, cooling job growth, and in Florida and parts of Texas, property insurance premiums that have doubled or tripled since 2021. A $3,500 annual insurance bill becoming $9,000 changes the math on a $450,000 house fast, and it shows up in resale demand.

Third, builders overshot in exactly the metros that got hottest. Markets like Phoenix, Austin, and parts of the Carolinas added new-construction inventory faster than population growth could absorb it. New builds compete directly with resale listings, and builders routinely offer rate buydowns and closing cost credits that resale sellers can't easily match.

Meanwhile, metros that never saw the 2020-2022 spike, think much of the industrial Midwest and parts of the Northeast, didn't have as far to fall. Supply there stayed tight because fewer new homes got built in the first place.

Where Prices Are Still Climbing

The metros holding or gaining value in 2026 tend to share a few traits: limited new construction, stable or growing local job bases outside of tech, and starter-home price points that remain within reach of local wages.

Much of the Midwest, places like Columbus, Indianapolis, and parts of Michigan, continues to see median days on market in the 20-30 day range, with multiple-offer situations still common on well-priced listings under $350,000. The Northeast corridor outside the most expensive metro cores, including parts of Connecticut, upstate New York, and New Hampshire, shows similar resilience. Inventory in these markets rarely topped a two-month supply even at the national slowdown's worst point, and a tight supply floor under prices tends to hold even when demand softens a bit.

Say a seller in a mid-size Midwest metro lists a three-bedroom home at $285,000. With local inventory running under 2,000 active listings citywide and buyer demand steady from relocating families and local move-up buyers, that listing might see an offer within 10 to 14 days, sometimes above ask. That's the pattern playing out across a good chunk of the Rust Belt and parts of New England right now, not a guarantee, but a reasonable illustration of how tight supply behaves.

Where Prices Have Cooled or Reversed

The cooling list is longer than headlines from 2021 would have predicted. Parts of Austin, Boise, Phoenix, and several Florida metros, especially Cape Coral, North Port, and parts of Jacksonville, have seen price reductions stack up through 2025 and into 2026. Months of supply in some of these markets has climbed past 5-6 months, which is squarely in buyer's-market territory.

Florida deserves its own callout. Beyond insurance costs, new condo safety and reserve-funding requirements passed after the Surfside collapse have forced many condo associations to levy large special assessments, sometimes $20,000 to $50,000 per unit. That's pushed condo resale prices down sharply in several coastal metros, even while single-family homes in the same metro areas have held up better.

Days on market tell the story clearly. Where a tight Midwest metro might move a listing in two weeks, cooled Sun Belt metros are seeing average days on market of 55-75 days, with price cuts on 30-40% of active listings. That doesn't mean these markets are collapsing. It means sellers who priced based on 2022 comps are getting a correction, and buyers who waited out the frenzy finally have room to negotiate.

What the Split Means If You Need to Sell Fast

If your home sits in a cooling market and you need to sell on a deadline, whether that's a job relocation, a divorce settlement, an inherited property with carrying costs piling up, or a pre-foreclosure timeline, the traditional listing path carries real risk right now. A home that might have sold in two weeks in 2021 could sit for two to three months in 2026, and every month on market usually means another price cut.

The math gets concrete fast. A $350,000 listing sitting for 75 days means roughly $2,500-$3,000 in carrying costs (taxes, insurance, utilities, and maintenance) even before you factor in the stress of showings and the risk of the buyer's financing falling through late in the process. Add a typical 5-6% agent commission and $3,000-$8,000 in seller-paid closing costs, and a slow sale in a cooling market can cost far more than the headline sale price suggests.

This is exactly the gap a cash offer is built to close. A cash buyer isn't waiting on an appraisal contingency or a mortgage underwriter, and closing in 7-14 days instead of 45-60 removes most of the carrying-cost bleed. The tradeoff is usually a lower offer than a top-of-market retail sale, somewhere in the range of 80-90% of as-is value depending on condition and local competition among cash buyers. For a seller comparing a guaranteed close in two weeks against three more months of price cuts and uncertainty, that tradeoff is worth running the numbers on, not assuming either way.

What the Split Means for Buyers and Investors

For first-time buyers, cooling markets are where negotiating leverage has actually returned. Seller concessions covering 2-3% of the purchase price toward closing costs are back on the table in much of Florida, Arizona, and parts of Texas, something that was unheard of in 2021. If you've been priced out of a hot market, a cooling one with price cuts and seller credits is where your offer finally gets taken seriously.

For small investors building a rental portfolio, the calculation is different from a homebuyer's. Cap rates matter more than appreciation right now. A cooling market with falling prices but stable rents can actually improve cash-on-cash returns, because you're buying the same rent roll for less money. Say an investor is weighing a $220,000 duplex in a softening Sun Belt metro against a $240,000 duplex in a tight Midwest market with the same $2,100 monthly combined rent. The lower-priced property, even in a market with flat appreciation, pencils out to a better cap rate on day one. Appreciation is a bonus, not the plan.

The risk for investors in cooling Sun Belt metros is insurance and HOA costs eating into that math. Before running numbers on any property in Florida, coastal Texas, or hurricane-exposed Gulf Coast metros, get a real insurance quote, not a seller's estimate from two years ago. A policy that was $2,800 in 2021 could easily be $7,000-$9,000 now, and that difference changes a solid cash-flow property into a break-even one.

How to Check Where Your Market Stands

Before you list, price, or make an offer, pull three numbers for your specific zip code: months of supply, median days on market, and the percentage of active listings with a price cut. Most state Realtor association sites and major portals publish these at the metro level, and some break it down by zip code.

As a rough read: under 3 months of supply and under 30 days on market signals a seller-favorable market. Over 5 months of supply and over 60 days on market signals buyer leverage. Anything in between is a market in transition, and that's often where pricing strategy matters more than timing.

If your numbers land in cooling territory and your timeline doesn't allow for three months of showings and price reductions, get a cash offer alongside a traditional listing estimate before deciding. Comparing both side by side, net proceeds after carrying costs and commissions versus a fast, firm cash number, tells you more than either option does alone.

The national housing story in 2026 isn't one direction. It's dozens of local stories moving at different speeds, shaped by insurance costs, supply decisions made by builders years ago, and where remote work actually landed. Knowing which story your zip code is telling changes whether you should wait for a better offer or take a sure one now.

Get competing cash offers on your home, no fees, close in days, at homedinero.com